CO129-260 - Governor Sir Robinson Acting Governor O-Brien - 1893 [9-12] — Page 82

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

and to give those exercises, which should be introduced into such lessons, but the suggestion has not been adopted in certain classes. With a view to raising the standard of results above that obtained in the old Central School, works for translation into English classes have to be rendered in language which is beyond the comprehension of the boys, a difficulty fatal to teaching, for which is substituted a meaningless and valueless "parrot-like" process, producing results that are less than genuine.

"The teaching to Chinese boys of a language so different in structure from their own must always be a work of peculiar difficulty, but we strongly feel that we have been unwilling accomplices in an attempt to show that results have been achieved which have never been attempted, and to pass off sham effects as the results of genuine teaching."

Secondly, in regard to the Oxford Local Examinations. They compel the first class to look for their final tests in January and July, not only wasting the time of the boys but concentrating the work of the majority of the masters to such an extent that half the pupils above the Preparatory school never see an English teacher save for an occasional lesson in Reading or in (so-called) Translation. More than this, they are far beyond the work of the first class, and the meagre results obtained are almost wholly due to private tuition outside school hours. Such boys are mainly monitors or Eurasian pupils who have had special facilities for the acquirement of English.

The interests of the entire school are sacrificed; the majority of...

Oxford Local.

C. O. 178/281

RECR D.D

Edit History

2026-05-27 03:52:55 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
and to give those exercises, which should be introduced into such lessons, but the suggestion has not been adopted in certain classes. With a view to raising the standard of results above that obtained in the old Central School, works for translation into English classes have to be rendered in language which is beyond the comprehension of the boys, a difficulty fatal to teaching, for which is substituted a meaningless and valueless "parrot-like" process, producing results that are less than genuine. "The teaching to Chinese boys of a language so different in structure from their own must always be a work of peculiar difficulty, but we strongly feel that we have been unwilling accomplices in an attempt to show that results have been achieved which have never been attempted, and to pass off sham effects as the results of genuine teaching." Secondly, in regard to the Oxford Local Examinations. They compel the first class to look for their final tests in January and July, not only wasting the time of the boys but concentrating the work of the majority of the masters to such an extent that half the pupils above the Preparatory school never see an English teacher save for an occasional lesson in Reading or in (so-called) Translation. More than this, they are far beyond the work of the first class, and the meagre results obtained are almost wholly due to private tuition outside school hours. Such boys are mainly monitors or Eurasian pupils who have had special facilities for the acquirement of English. The interests of the entire school are sacrificed; the majority of... Oxford Local. C. O. 178/281 RECR D.D
Baseline (Original)
English and to give those exercises. which should be introduced into has in certain. in such lessons, but the suggestion not been adopted!. With a view to raising the standard of results above that obtained in the old Central School, works for translation into inglisă classes have to be rendered in language which is beyond the comprehension of the boys, a difficulty fatal to teaching, for which is substituted a zys, L of chann genuine -producing results ·less and valueless. meaningless "The teaching to Chinese boys of a language so different in structure nom their own must always is " peculiar difficulty, but we strongly be a work Feel that we have been unwilling accomplices in an attempt to show that that has been done, which has never results as the been attempted, and to pass off sham effects of genuine teaching. Oxford * Oxford Local. C. O. 1781281 RECR D.D Secondly in regard to the Oxford Local Examinations. They compel the first class to look for hos final tests, one inn July and are in January, not only wasting the time of the boys but concentrating the work of the majority of the masters to such an extent that half the pupils above the Preparatory school never see an save for h teacher. English an occasional lesson in Read. or in (so-called) Franslation. ing More than this, they · far beyond are wo the work of the first class that the meagre results obtained are almost wholly due to private tuition outside school hours. Such boys are mainly monitors or as do pass Eurasians who have had special facilities for the acquirement of English. The interests of the entire school are sacrificed, the majority of the Z..A
2026-05-27 03:52:55 · Baseline
View content

English

and to

give

those exercises.

which should be introduced into

has

in certain.

in

such lessons, but the suggestion not been adopted!. With a view to raising the standard of results above that obtained in the old Central School, works for translation into inglisă classes have to be rendered in language which is beyond the comprehension of the boys, a difficulty fatal to teaching, for which is substituted a

zys,

L

of

chann

genuine

-producing results

·less and valueless.

meaningless

"The teaching to Chinese boys

of a language

so different in structure

nom their own must always

is

" peculiar difficulty, but we strongly

be a work

Feel

that we have been unwilling accomplices in an attempt to show that that has been done, which has never

results as

the

been attempted, and to pass off sham

effects of genuine teaching.

Oxford

*

Oxford Local.

C. O.

1781281

RECR

D.D

Secondly in regard to the Oxford Local Examinations. They compel the

first class to look for hos final tests,

one inn

July

and are

in

January, not only wasting the time of the boys but concentrating

the work of the majority

of the masters to such an extent that half the pupils above the Preparatory

school never see an

save

for

h teacher.

English

an occasional lesson in Read.

or in (so-called) Franslation. ing More than this, they · far beyond

are wo

the work of the first class that the meagre results obtained are almost wholly due to private tuition outside school hours. Such boys

are

mainly

monitors or

as do

• pass Eurasians

who have had special facilities for

the acquirement of English.

The interests of the entire school are sacrificed, the majority of

the

Z..A

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.